• Handles
    link
    English
    244 months ago

    I’d never heard of Servo before this, but judging from the website it’s nowhere near a GUI offering. The work they’re doing on the engine looks solid (to me as not-a-developer) but it’s a telltale sign that there are no UI screenshots on their landing page. So, not an alternative to Firefox yet.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      204 months ago

      Because, as pointed in the page, Servo is being developed as a(n embeddable) Rendering Engine, not as a full blown end user Browser.
      Its alternatives are not Chrome, Safari or Firefox, but Webkit, Blink and Gecko

      There’s an example GUI called Servoshell, but it is more of a testing ground and example on how to embed the engine in an app than a serious alternative to anything currently in the market.

      Already this kind of work is difficult and daunting. Adding to it a full GUI would make it completely impossible for the current size and financial backing Servo has.

      Big words aside it just means that Servo wants to be only one of the parts that compose a real browser: the one that takes HTML, Javascript, WASM and translates them into the things you see on your monitor. All the user facing functionality are left to the devs of the app that embed it.

      • Handles
        link
        English
        34 months ago

        Thanks for the big word elaboration! 👍

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      134 months ago

      While it’s not an alternative right now, I think Servo’s focus on being embeddable might help it in the long run. A big issue with Gecko is that it was difficult, if not impossible to embed. It’d be nice to see something like Vivaldi that runs on Servo.

      • Handles
        link
        English
        64 months ago

        Oh, that’s fair. I’m not complaining about the work being put into a new browser engine, and there is definitely space for improvement over the ones we have.

        Vivaldi, though? I’d vastly prefer an open source browser, and maybe one with less baggage than Vivaldi has — but I’ll look forward to any GUI implementation of Servo, when and if, etc.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          34 months ago

          I was more talking about Vivaldi feature-wise, FWIW. There’s features I’d like from Vivaldi that don’t have a close equivalent to Firefox, not even from its forks (tab tiling’s my go-to example), and maybe in the distant future, there’d be a browser like it running on Servo.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            54 months ago

            @Flaky @halm be nice if you could just essentially plug-in engines and swap them out etc
            in theory they are all supposed to support the same standards

            • Handles
              link
              English
              34 months ago

              Hmm. Now there’s an idea for developers. Some kind of modular compatibility standard.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      54 months ago

      Obviously not. Building a modern browser engine from scratch is an immense undertaking, so it’s definitely possible that it will never be usable as a replacement for every day webbrowsing. But for now I won’t give up hope :)