Curious about the stability of using Photoshop with Wine or a VM. Photoshop and Marvelous Designer are the only apps I use that aren’t on linux. I wonder if using Wine for Photoshop would be simplified if people try a version like m0nkrus that doesn’t require the creative cloud.
You must log in or register to comment.
I don’t know what you heard about me
It’s the motherduckin G I M P
I’m so glad I started using Linux before getting used too much to something that doesn’t support it. (If you have the time to try out different things, give Krita a shot)
I’ve tried Krita, it’s getting there but its still not great
My need for the Adobe CC Suite professionally is what keeps me from switching to Linux as a daily driver (currently on macOS). If I could get the latest version running reliably on Linux, I’d love to switch.
I’ve tried the alternatives, and they’re just not good enough for me. I really wish Adobe would port their stuff to Linux.
The best we can ever hope for are CC browser versions. They’ll never create a native Linux port. At least not in the next 10 years. :(
I feel like Pixlr is very very close to being a browser based version of photo shop. But still not quite the same
Boo!
I went in hard.
I’m using Photoshop creative cloud on the web, switched illustrator for Inkscape (the CC version is in alpha stage). Davinci resolve and kdenlive, Scribus sucked so hard that I gave up my InDesign tasks.
Cheers to you, mate, really. I might fiddle with photoshop web…
But I’m on a production timeline most of the time, and I need everything to work and interoperate seamlessly in my workflow, which is part of why CC is so great for me. Plus, I don’t pay for it. If I did, this would be a very different conversation, lol!
I completely get why you’d stick with MacOS if you need CC software. That being said I am very glad about the general lack of anti-user software like Adobe’s suite on Linux and I hope they don’t port their CC software to Linux. Instead I hope FOSS alternatives get better to the point where most PS/CC users can reasonably meet all their needs with free (as in libre) software. GIMP is pretty decent these days although I find it a lot more clunky and awkward to use than PS. But hopefully either the gap can close or some new FOSS developer can create an even better alternative.
I recently went through a process of trying out all the options for photo processing on linux. I dont do drawing, just raw Nikon files for processing, so I have a slightly different set of criteria.
Darktable and RawThreapee produce reasonable results, but the UI’s are a mess and far far too complicated. They’re on the right track, but I felt like I was being asked to enter every parameter in to a complex API function with no idea what anything meant. For some people they’re probably fine, but you really don’t have to look far before the complexity is in your face and you’re just entering random numbers and crossing your fingers.
Nikon Studio NX in Wine is dog slow. Better in a windows VM on linux, but the results aren’t great.
GIMP isn’t targeted at raw photo editing.
Photolab in a windows VM is slow but excellent otherwise.
I ended up creating a dual boot windows setup and buying Photolab 7 Elite. I didn’t want to set up a windows disk as I’d been free of it for maybe 7 years now, but for this use case it’s definitely justified imho. The fact Photolab isn’t subscription based means its better than Lightroom. The noise reduction algorithms are outstanding, the workflow is nice and not tied to a database or a weird import process. The controls are logical and easy to use. And it reads the camera and lens used for each photo and applies the correct corrections to tour image automatically.
So not what I wanted to end up with as a solution, but the results are so good its a no brainer in the end.
For PS your only options are:
- run an ancient version of PS on Wine
- Subscribe to creative cloud and run PS online-only web version which has 80% of the features
- Use Photopea which has 95% of the features but it’s online only
- Use GIMP (horrible UX/UI but it’s offline and has 90% of the features)
- Use Krita (not the same, but some features are there)
I went with CC PS web, since I work for a company that requires the use of PS.
Why not use a modern version of PS without creative cloud so it doesnt break it?
They crash or are painfully slow.
I can’t even get the stability I need out of it on Windows.
It probably is possible to pirate an old version of photoshop and get it running under wine. Like other commenters have noted Krita and Gimp are becoming more viable all of the time.
My photo editing skills are too novice level to notice missing features in the linux alternatives but I’m sure they exist. Although part of me does wonder if some of the barrier to people adopting these is that they are photoshop “power users” who do a lot based on muscle memory… maybe the features aren’t all missing but the interface is just too different to feel “complete”.
No there are still legitimately essential things that Gimp lacks like adjustment layers. I hear they’re releasing this exact feature soon though. So, hopefully it will have parity with minimum viable photoshop VERRRRY soon.
Ps. Fuck Adobe.
Yeah I could believe that. Like I mentioned my knowledge of photo editing is basically 0!
Its funny but what i miss the most in Gimp is the ability to freely rotate the cropping tool. Its the one thing that breaks it for me
Using CS2 and works fine.
Have you tried any more recent versions?
Removed by mod
PARK AVENUE MANICURE SNEED’S FEED JANNIES HOT POCKETS SEETHE FANCY GERMAN CAR ON LEMMY CHUCK SEED GUCCI LOAFERS ON LEMMY PARK AVENUE MANICURE AND ON LEMMY SEED JANNIES SNEED’S AND CITY SLICKER SEETHE FANCY GERMAN CAR JANNY CHUCK PARK AVENUE MANICURE JANNY CLEAN IT UP FUCK FANCY GERMAN CAR CITY SLICKER SEETHE FEED AND FLOYD SEED HOT POCKETS SEED FEED JANNY GUCCI LOAFERS CITY SLICKER CITY SLICKER JANNIES SEETHE ON LEMMY SEED CITY SLICKER ON LEMMY I CAN’T FEED
HOT POCKETS CLEAN IT UP AND GUCCI LOAFERS SEED FANCY GERMAN CAR SNEED SEETHE SEETHE FUCK FOR FREE COPE FUCK AND CLEAN IT UP FUCK FANCY GERMAN CAR SUCK SNEED’S GUCCI LOAFERS JANNIES I CAN’T DILATE CHUCK FEED FEED SUCK SEED SNEED COPE CHUCK I CAN’T SNEED’S AND FEED FLOYD FLOYD DILATE FEED GUCCI LOAFERS CLEAN IT UP CHUCK FANCY GERMAN CAR JANNIES FANCY GERMAN CAR SEED SNEED’S SUCK ON LEMMY AND
GUCCI LOAFERS SEED CHUCK PARK AVENUE MANICURE SEETHE CITY SLICKER DILATE HOT POCKETS FUCK FANCY GERMAN CAR SEED CLEAN IT UP DILATE SNEED’S CHUCK’S FOR FREE SNEED’S CHUCK FLOYD SUCK SEED FLOYD AND CITY SLICKER FEED AND FANCY GERMAN CAR DILATE CITY SLICKER FEED FLOYD SNEED DILATE DILATE CHUCK’S CHUCK’S COPE SUCK CHUCK’S JANNIES AND CLEAN IT UP DILATE SNEED’S GUCCI LOAFERS PARK AVENUE MANICURE DILATE SNEED FLOYD I CAN’T
CITY SLICKER SEED CLEAN IT UP SEED SNEED FLOYD COPE ON LEMMY DILATE SEETHE GUCCI LOAFERS HOT POCKETS SNEED FEED JANNY JANNY FEED SEED SNEED SNEED COPE JANNY ON LEMMY JANNIES DILATE SNEED’S FEED DILATE FEED SNEED SEETHE COPE SNEED SUCK SEETHE SNEED’S CHUCK’S PARK AVENUE MANICURE SUCK CHUCK’S FUCK FEED SEED CHUCK’S CHUCK’S DILATE FLOYD FUCK SNEED’S JANNIES
CITY SLICKER PARK AVENUE MANICURE SNEED’S FANCY GERMAN CAR HOT POCKETS HOT POCKETS GUCCI LOAFERS I CAN’T SEETHE SNEED’S CHUCK SEED SEETHE HOT POCKETS GUCCI LOAFERS FLOYD SEETHE FUCK SEETHE JANNIES CLEAN IT UP FLOYD CHUCK I CAN’T SEED COPE CHUCK’S FOR FREE COPE CHUCK COPE SNEED JANNIES COPE FEED FUCK GUCCI LOAFERS CHUCK AND GUCCI LOAFERS CITY SLICKER GUCCI LOAFERS DILATE CHUCK’S FUCK HOT POCKETS I CAN’T GUCCI LOAFERS JANNY HOT POCKETS
AND FUCK SNEED FANCY GERMAN CAR JANNY SUCK FEED COPE HOT POCKETS CHUCK HOT POCKETS I CAN’T FEED AND JANNIES HOT POCKETS CITY SLICKER FANCY GERMAN CAR FANCY GERMAN CAR HOT POCKETS SNEED’S FOR FREE CHUCK DILATE JANNY CHUCK’S CLEAN IT UP SEETHE GUCCI LOAFERS CLEAN IT UP COPE JANNY HOT POCKETS FUCK FEED SEED FLOYD GUCCI LOAFERS FLOYD CLEAN IT UP JANNIES SUCK SUCK CLEAN IT UP HOT POCKETS I CAN’T ON LEMMY I CAN’T COPE CLEAN IT UP
