Pisha [she/her, they/them]

  • 0 Posts
  • 20 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: December 23rd, 2020

help-circle










  • I’d like to rant about LGBT erasure in academia for a bit. Specifically, historians become incredibly angry when you suggest that Ancient Romans who were assigned male, wore women’s clothing, castrated themselves and married men were trans. You’ll hear complaints about how it’s ahistorical to use a contemporary label for the past, but I never understood that kind of criticism. It’s not like being transgender is a random social identity or subculture without any deeper meaning; it refers, roughly speaking, to a certain combination of behaviors that transgress the bounds of gender assignment. So when I say that Elagabalus, for example, was probably a trans woman, I don’t mean that she consciously thought about herself in our contemporary terms, but that from what those admittedly questionable Roman historians write of her, she expressed a strong wish to be and be seen as a woman. I think it’s fair to use the term “trans” for that.

    Personally, I blame both old-fashioned positivists and Foucault for these brainworms. I think they both agree that you must understand the past from within itself, and not by relating it to the present. For me, that’s so far away from my lived experience and from the way I approach texts that I just can’t fathom it.




  • I have so many mean things to say about BG3, but instead I’ll be positive and say that in my opinion, Pathfinder: WotR combines all the best parts of the old Baldur’s Gate games (well-told, if a bit generic, story; fantastical setting that doesn’t go too far overboard; interesting and sympathetic companions) with a ruleset that offers many options for character building and highly adjustable difficulty settings. There’s a crusade minigame which is a real drag, but that’s the only real bad thing about the whole game. Also, the different paths – the big ones at least – make enough of a difference that there’s some replayability. It doesn’t reach the narrative heights of Torment or Mask of the Betrayer, but neither does BG3 (not even remotely).