in terms of pure theory and knowledge Rev Left and the extended Breht Cinematic Universe (Guerilla History, Red Menace) is the best of them. the rest just are like “gee shucks look at this event heres some leftist commentary” meanwhile f you go into Rev Left you will come out with so much communism you will be seeing blue and green because the red particles in your eyes have condensed into your heart

i already understand them and i dont give a fuck about discussing in an online forum

its performance in terms of being good is absolute shit as well as far as i’m seeing

da physics of the eye is also da same and our brains are all built roughly the same so whateva

i dont think you are engaging with the actual thinking going on and instead are being like “but what about the fact that we can never truly know anyone else!!!” it’s easy to understand. light is a phenomena that is pretty well explained in physics and with other “philosophical” or logical evidence. we’re not all seeing different shit even if it’s interesting to think about

why on gods green earth

just read a comment implying she condemns a Lot of parties - why is she like this ? just ask her why is she like this. there’s no built up movement in the West. there’s no need to keep other far leftists/communists ideologically arguing about things that are so far in the future that no communist line could possibly be predicted to come out on top yet

what does she want done about China? if it’s “a people’s revolution built to overthrow the PRC” then whatever, it’s in neither of your hands. if she can’t find a “revolution” she won’t support (like if she genuinely thinks the HK protests were anything but bourgeois tantruming) and propagates/defends any threat to China’s stability then she’s ideologically bankrupt, you can stay with her but like, outside of broad movement building type things you should just write her ideas on revolution and defending it off