• 482 Posts
  • 304 Comments
Joined 6 months ago
cake
Cake day: May 20th, 2025

help-circle



















  • There was no takeover of Christianity in Rome. There was a takeover of Rome in Christianity. Rome imposed creeds, hierarchies, even councils to the church before the conversion of the emperors and the official christianization of the Empire because the Empire wanted to control the new faith. After that there was an imperial church and a lot of “heresies”, which were fought by the imperial church. One of the decisions of Julian was to cancel the obligation for Christians to subscribe to the imperial christian creed, freeing in fact Christianity.

    And this should be a lesson of how the State and the religions should be separated, for the good of the State and of the religions themselves. As a Christian, I prefer Julian over Constantine.













  • You grew up in a church or a few churches. There’s no such thing as “the” church… In a lot of churches, morality is kind of a very secondary thing for example, and the idea that someone has to be pure is totally foreign.

    You obviously had a very bad experience growing up, and there are a lot of very fucked up communities, so it’s not surprising. But saying “the Christians are…” is no different than saying “the people engaged in a political party are…” without distinguishing between Democrats, Republicans and third parties. You can’t say for example that DSA is a fascist party because the Republicans are.





  • As a very liberal and active European Protestant, I would add that, unfortunately, American evangelicalism exerts a strong influence on European Protestantism. The Lutheran Church of Latvia, for example, decided a few years ago to stop ordaining women pastors. In my (French) church, new pastors are on average more conservative than their predecessors (but the remaining liberal pastors are even more so than their predecessors). Evangelicals have the resources and use them extensively; they are winning the cultural battle, unfortunately. Protestant churches are still resisting, but we will have to learn to make ourselves heard if we don’t want sectarianism to set us back a century or two.