I do believe this was made with best intentions but it has major “just be happy” energy and is made from a position of privilege.
Just getting a therapist for example is a huge battle. Having supportive friends is not ubiquitous. Changing jobs is risky and in certain financial circumstances almost impossible, especially with dependents.
That said I approve of the message that without living there is no possibility of things getting better. My advice is to focus on small maybe even tiny victories daily making lifestyle changes where possible.
I respectfully disagree. Its thesis is simply that you can have a better life if you stay alive. The “proof” is simply all the changes the artist went through in order to find a better life. The changes aren’t supposed to be a recipe on how to make your life better - I don’t think the artist is telling people to divorce their spouses. There isn’t anything “just be happy” about getting a divorce.
Fair enough, I think yours is also a valid interpretation.
I just want to clarify: with “just be happy” energy, I meant the tendency of people to suggest seemingly simple fixes to others struggling with mental health. Even, if they work for oneself and even if it works statistically (for example sport is a good habit against depression), it feels like talking the problem down. But that is highly subjective of course.
And I do believe, that it’s not the comic that was made from the position of privilege, but your fucking comment. Who the hell are you to approve it or not and spread out your advice instead? Come on, check yourself first
I just commented on how I personally perceived the comic. I also said that I believe that the comic was made with good intentions.
Ultimately, I am just someone on the Internet. I have no illusion that my comments here matter. Though, I do have first and second hand experience with depression and suicide if that matters, which it does not.
And yes in many ways I am extremely privileged when it comes to this topic, e.g. my healthcare insurance is not tied to my employer as I don’t live in the US. I would like to know how that has anything to do with my comment above though.
Privilege? Risk? The guy was about to kill himself. He had nothing to lose. I see your point on kids, but barring significant hurdles (which most people don’t actually have), most people motivated enough can significantly change their circumstances. They just don’t want to.
I have a phone call a to crisis centers who told me “you don’t have a crisis” and hung up on me. I have a recording of an on-call psychiatrist tossing me out of the ER after saying “don’t try making this my responsibility” after I literally said I’m afraid I’ll hurt myself or others, and asked what happens if I walk out of there and toss myself under a truck. “Don try making this my responsibility.” Like, my man, it’s literally your legal duty ffs.
I’ve got photos of an isolation cell the cops put me because they denied me my prescription meds and I went a bit cuckoo from the way they treated me. (absolutely no information of rights I didn’t know if I was detained or arrested or to be put in prison), and I drew over 300 words in my own blood on the walls. No-one helped. Up for three days, supposedly under supervision. The only thing I got was them cutting off my water and snide remarks bullying me on the radio.
Several dozen doctors who’ve just dismissed me.
Literally all of my family and friends, when I even carefully try to talk about suicidal ideation, they’ll cut me off for months and months. My mom hasn’t rang me for several years to ask me how I am. Yet they all pretend it’s my fault and my personal failing that I’m not getting help, because every single one thinks “not my responsibility”, and that includes an on-call psychiatrist I told I’m afraid of harming people.
So yeah, kindly fuck off with your victim blaming.
“significant hurdles Which most people don’t actually have”
Interesting argument against privilege… buddy, we know you’ve had an easy life so far, which is great for you, yet no one thinks this way due to careful observation of others.
Quitting your job, potentially losing your shelter and food supply is a hell of a risk. Presume one actually wants to get better, they first need to be well enough to handle such a risk. Otherwise, they are homeless and suicidal: A great recipe to get well /s
I do believe this was made with best intentions but it has major “just be happy” energy and is made from a position of privilege.
Just getting a therapist for example is a huge battle. Having supportive friends is not ubiquitous. Changing jobs is risky and in certain financial circumstances almost impossible, especially with dependents.
That said I approve of the message that without living there is no possibility of things getting better. My advice is to focus on small maybe even tiny victories daily making lifestyle changes where possible.
I respectfully disagree. Its thesis is simply that you can have a better life if you stay alive. The “proof” is simply all the changes the artist went through in order to find a better life. The changes aren’t supposed to be a recipe on how to make your life better - I don’t think the artist is telling people to divorce their spouses. There isn’t anything “just be happy” about getting a divorce.
Fair enough, I think yours is also a valid interpretation.
I just want to clarify: with “just be happy” energy, I meant the tendency of people to suggest seemingly simple fixes to others struggling with mental health. Even, if they work for oneself and even if it works statistically (for example sport is a good habit against depression), it feels like talking the problem down. But that is highly subjective of course.
And I do believe, that it’s not the comic that was made from the position of privilege, but your fucking comment. Who the hell are you to approve it or not and spread out your advice instead? Come on, check yourself first
Ok, what do you mean by checking myself first?
I just commented on how I personally perceived the comic. I also said that I believe that the comic was made with good intentions.
Ultimately, I am just someone on the Internet. I have no illusion that my comments here matter. Though, I do have first and second hand experience with depression and suicide if that matters, which it does not.
And yes in many ways I am extremely privileged when it comes to this topic, e.g. my healthcare insurance is not tied to my employer as I don’t live in the US. I would like to know how that has anything to do with my comment above though.
Privilege? Risk? The guy was about to kill himself. He had nothing to lose. I see your point on kids, but barring significant hurdles (which most people don’t actually have), most people motivated enough can significantly change their circumstances. They just don’t want to.
I can upload some data for you.
I have a phone call a to crisis centers who told me “you don’t have a crisis” and hung up on me. I have a recording of an on-call psychiatrist tossing me out of the ER after saying “don’t try making this my responsibility” after I literally said I’m afraid I’ll hurt myself or others, and asked what happens if I walk out of there and toss myself under a truck. “Don try making this my responsibility.” Like, my man, it’s literally your legal duty ffs.
I’ve got photos of an isolation cell the cops put me because they denied me my prescription meds and I went a bit cuckoo from the way they treated me. (absolutely no information of rights I didn’t know if I was detained or arrested or to be put in prison), and I drew over 300 words in my own blood on the walls. No-one helped. Up for three days, supposedly under supervision. The only thing I got was them cutting off my water and snide remarks bullying me on the radio.
Several dozen doctors who’ve just dismissed me.
Literally all of my family and friends, when I even carefully try to talk about suicidal ideation, they’ll cut me off for months and months. My mom hasn’t rang me for several years to ask me how I am. Yet they all pretend it’s my fault and my personal failing that I’m not getting help, because every single one thinks “not my responsibility”, and that includes an on-call psychiatrist I told I’m afraid of harming people.
So yeah, kindly fuck off with your victim blaming.
“significant hurdles Which most people don’t actually have”
Interesting argument against privilege… buddy, we know you’ve had an easy life so far, which is great for you, yet no one thinks this way due to careful observation of others.
What do you mean with “they just don’t want to”?
Quitting your job, potentially losing your shelter and food supply is a hell of a risk. Presume one actually wants to get better, they first need to be well enough to handle such a risk. Otherwise, they are homeless and suicidal: A great recipe to get well /s